How sports people started to make massage readily available
Several years ago sports, athletics and personal trainers saw the success and benefits others derived by using massage. They wanted it for their clients. The question was how to access this valuable therapy at a reasonable cost. Some came up with a self massage technique where one basically uses one’s body weight on a foam roller. This emulates manual massage. According to it’s proponents it may not be as effective as having a professional masseur, but one can get practically unlimited massage for a single small cost.
People trying to help themselves is a very good idea, and the use of foam rollers is certainly better than nothing. However, some muscles are difficult to access this way, and foam rolling requires a reasonable degree of skill to perform properly. Persons would need a good knowledge of anatomy and technique, but more importantly in adjusting the pressure applied one would need to be able to extinguish between the level of discomfort related to trigger points and a potential injurious situation. If a person does misjudge this they would cause injury or further worsen an existing problem.
What the research shows
A review of the trials done on the use of foam rollers (see appendix 1) shows a mixed bag. Some found that that the foam rollers were quite effective, while others showed no benefits at all. This author's theory is that myofascial release, the soft tissue therapy that the use of foam rollers is trying to emulate, is very effective. If skilfully used a foam roller could produce a similar result. However, users would need an excellent knowledge of the relevant anatomy and so forth, and be able to distinguish between the "good pain" of an effective massage, and the pain of tissue injury. With those variables some inconsistent results would be expected. Simply speaking, some would get it right, some would be ineffectual, while others would be injuring themselves thinking that they were doing good. It must be considered though that the protocols of the trials would have been rigorously supervised. In the trials any subject with an injury would have been excluded, and the procedures meticulously explained. What would happen in the real world with less supervision, less meticulous teaching of techniques, and and people with injuries not being excluded?
Introducing the home use of vibration massage
Like those involved with sports and athletics we at DrGraeme saw the need to make massage more readily available, though not just for sports but for the many other reasons including those discussed at the beginning of this article. The way we chose to fill this need was to develop a serious hand held massager capable of producing professional results while being suitable for use by the public. How does vibration massage compared with the use of foam rollers?
Ease of use
Rather than have to manoeuvre one's body weight and adjust one's position to emulate the pressure of a manual masseur, all one has to do is place the massager head on the appropriate part and let the vibrations do the work. There is no need to try and adjust the pressure to achieve the "good pain". In fact, as one does not need to press in there is usually little or no pain, and probably less potential to cause injury.
This used to be a significant factor. As a generalisation, previously serious hand held massagers were only built in small numbers with high budget marketing aimed at sales to professionals. They were very expensive compared to a simple foam roller. At DrGraeme we've changed that, now having a very seriously capable massager available to all at a very reasonable price. They are still more expensive than a foam roller, but probably no more expensive than a single hour with a professional masseur.
Vibration massager are very convenient, but they still need to be plugged into a power supply
Do they work?
Clinical trials show the application of vibration massage to work well (See appendix 2).
Some issues when using vibration massage
General health and preventative uses
Vibration massage is a relatively safe. If people without serious issues use them with a few simple precautions there should be no problem. This means that there should be no great issues with healthy people using them for things such as pre-sport, post-sport, general maintenance, wellbeing, and after a hard day's work. For an initial basic investment a user can have practically unlimited quality massage.
Injuries and pain syndromes
The use of hand held vibration massagers can be a powerful and effective form of therapy. However, if one has any sort of injury or pain syndrome this needs to be investigated by a qualified professional who can advise the most appropriate management and treatment plan, which may include massage. Lets look at how this might work in practice.
An example of quality professional management using supplementary self massage
Let us use an example of a professional sports person injuring his or her ankle. A qualified practitioner perform an examination. If warranted further investigations could be ordered. Initially the injury would probably be supported with a brace or a bandage, with ice applied. Massage may be appropriate for the calf muscles at this stage, but certainly not for the injury itself. As the injury healed the qualified practitioner would perform further examination, provide advice, exercises and possibly use manual joint mobilisation. At this stage some sort of massage therapy may be very useful. The patient could apply regular massage using a hand held massager, under the advice of the qualified practitioner managing the case. During this process the practitioner would monitor the progress and adjust the management as necessary.
Appendix One: The research on the use of foam rollers
The treatment group performed self massages using a foam roller over an eight week period. The length of the hamstrings was measures by measuring knee extension with the hip at 90 degrees flexion. Compared with the control group no significant difference was found.
The effect of using foam roller on various aspects of athletics performance were measured. No improvement was found.
Hip extension was measured using a lunge. After one week there was some improvement. The use of five sessions a week produced no further improvement. However, participants felt satisfied with their intervention and were happy with the feeling of self control.
Both hip extension and knee extension were measured. There was a small increase in hip extension, but none for knee flexion.
Hamstring length was assess using hip flexion with the knee extended. The use of foam rollers caused an increase in length.
Hamstring flexibility was assessed using a sit and reach test. The use of foam rollers was shown to increase hamstring flexibility.
A four week trial measured hamstring length using a reach test. Both PNF stretching and the use of foam rollers were assessed. Both showed a similar increase in length.
Hamstring length was assessed by measuring knee extension with the hip at 90 degrees. Foam rollers produced no improvement.
(1) Miller, Rockey Foam Rollers Show No Increase in the Flexibility of the Hamstring UW-L Journal of Undergraduate Research IX (2006)
(2) Healey KC1, Hatfield DL, Blanpied P, Dorfman LR, Riebe D. The effects of myofascial release with foam rolling on performance. J Strength Cond Res. 2014 Jan;28(1):61-8
(3) Bushell JE1, Dawson SM, Webster MM. Clinical Relevance of Foam Rolling on Hip Extension Angle in a Functional Lunge Position. J Strength Cond Res. 2015 Sep;29(9):2397-403.
(4) Vigotsky AD1, Lehman GJ2, Contreras B3, Beardsley C4, Chung B5, Feser EH1. . Acute effects of anterior thigh foam rolling on hip angle, knee angle, and rectus femoris length in the modified Thomas test. PeerJ. 2015 Sep 24;3:e1281
(5) Mohr AR1, Long BC, Goad CL Effect of foam rolling and static stretching on passive hip-flexion range of motion. J Sport Rehabil. 2014 Nov;23(4):296-9
(6) Sullivan KM1, Silvey DB, Button DC, Behm DG. Roller-massager application to the hamstrings increases sit-and-reach range of motion within five to ten seconds without performance impairments. ) Int J Sports Phys Ther. 2013 Jun;8(3):228-36.
(7) Junker DH1, Stöggl TL The Foam Roll as a Tool to Improve Hamstring Flexibility. J Strength Cond Res. 2015 Dec;29(12):3480-5
(8) Grace Couture, Dustin Karlik, Stephen C Glass,* and Brian M Hatzel The Effect of Foam Rolling Duration on Hamstring Range of Motion Open Orthop J. 2015; 9: 450–455.
Appendix Two: The evidence on the use of vibration massage
Increased recovery and reduced post exercise soreness
In each trial strenuous exercise to induce post exercise soreness and fatigue.
THE FIRST TRIAL
In this trial one third of participants had no treatment. One third were given conventional massage. The third group had their muscle massaged before exercise using a vibrating massager set at 50Hz (cycles per second). The results showed that both the conventional massage and the vibration massage resulted in significantly lower DOMS, with the vibration group recovering faster than the conventional massage group. They also showed that the group receiving the vibration massage had significantly less residual Lactic Acid.
THE SECOND TRIAL
In this trial the treatment group received a vibration massage of 50Hz to the centre of the muscle. There was a significant decrease in the soreness of the vibration massage group compared with the control. Muscles showed a decrease in maximum contraction strength post exercise, but this decrease was less in the vibration massage group.
THE THIRDD TRIAL
In this trial the treatment group received a vibration massage of 30-50Hz, with the vibration massage group showing a significantly lower level of pain.
THE FOURTH TRIAL
This trial used the combined intervention of having the exercise performed on a vibrating platform, and applying vibration massage to the muscles. They found significantly reduced pain 24-120 hours after exercise for the treatment group, plus blood chemistry tests showed that an immune response was produced.
THE FIFTH TRIAL
This trial Used a vibration pad giving 30-65Hz, with 30 minute massages being given 30 minutes post exercise plus on days 1,2 3 and 4. Compared with the control, from days 2-5 soreness was 18-30% less, with soreness disappearing altogether earlier.
THE SCIENTIFIC REVIEW ONE
“Vibration is an effective modality in the field of rehabilitation. Vibration therapy improves muscular strength, power development and kinaesthetic awareness , increased flexibility, motor unit synchronisation. Various researches which shows effectiveness of vibration therapy in management of DOMS”
THE SCIENTIFIC REVIEW TWO
“Vibration therapy before eccentric exercise may prevent and control DOMS”
(1) Imtiyaz S1, Veqar Z2, Shareef MY3 To Compare the Effect of Vibration Therapy and Massage in Prevention of Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness (DOMS). J Clin Diagn Res. 2014 Jan;8(1):133-6
(2) Bakhtiary AH, Safavi Farokhi Z, Aminian Far A. Influence of vibration on delayed onset of muscle soreness following eccentric exercise. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2007;41(3):145-148.
.(3) Kamandani et.al. The Effect of Acute Vibration Training on Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness in Young Non-Athlete Women Health Scope. 2013 November; 2(3): 119-24
(4) Broadbent, S., Rousseau, J.J., Thorp, R.M., Choate, S.L., Jackson, F.S. and Rowlands, D.S. (2010) Vibration therapy reduces plasma IL6 and muscle soreness after downhill running. British Journal of Sports Medicine 44(Pt 12), 888-894
(5) Lau, W.Y. and Nosaka, K. (2011) Effect of vibration treatment on symptoms associated with eccentric exercise-induced muscle damage. American Journal of Physiology Medicine & Rehabilitation 90(Pt 8), 648-657
(6) Zubia Veqar, Shagufta Imtiyaz Vibration Therapy in Management of Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness (DOMS). J Clin Diagn Res 2014 Jun 20;8(6)
(7) Sethi V. Literature review of Management of Delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS) Int J Biol Med Res. 2012; 3(1): 1469-1475
Research on the effect of vibration massage on joint range of motion (ROM)
In all the trials vibration massage was applied to muscles. Joint ranges of motion were measured, with increase being due to a lengthening of those muscles allowing the joint to move further,
THE FIRST TRIAL
Knee extension was measured with the hip flexed to 90 degrees. Multiple applications of 50 Hz (cycles per second) massage were applied to the hamstring muscles over a eight week period. Compared with the control group the massage THE SECOND TRIAL
Hip flexion was measured by attempting to touch ones toes. For the massage group a 44 Hz massage was applied each day to the hamstrings for three days. A stretching group used conventional stretches each day, while a third group acted as a control. Both the stretching and massage groups showed a similar significant improvement in hip joint ROM
THE THIRD TRIAL
This trial used the toe touching measurement and hamstring massage. Vibration massage was used with unspecified protocol on the hamstrings and erector spinae muscles. The massage group showed a 5cm improvement as compared to the controls.
THE FOURTH TRIAL
In this trial a straight leg raise was measured. A proprietary device called “Deep Oscillation” was used. This is a device that has a pad that applies to the skin. The makers claim that it’s therapeutic affect is from mechanical vibrations that penetrate. From what I understand the pad creates an electrostatic attraction to the skin that switches on and off. It works like having a vacuum cleaner on your skin switching on and off very fast creating a vibration. In other words, it’s an impressive looking, patentable and very expensive way to create a simple mechanical vibration. Anyway, the Deep Oscillation group had an increase in SLR over the controls.
(1) Bakhtiary AH1, Fatemi E, Khalili MA, Ghorbani R. Localised application of vibration improves passive knee extension in women with apparent reduced hamstring extensibility: a randomised trial. J Physiother. 2011;57(3):165-71
(2) J. Atha and D. W. Wheatley Joint mobility changes due to low frequency vibration and stretching exercise* Br J Sports Med. 1976 Mar; 10(1): 26–34.
(3) Beirman W. INfluence of Cycloid Vibration Massage on Trunk Flexion American Journal of Physical Medicine: December 1960 - Volume 39 - Issue 6 - ppg 219-224
(4) Hinman, M. R., Lundy, R., Perry, E., Robbins, K., & Viertel, L. (2013). Comparative effect of ultrasound and deep oscillation on the extensibility of hamstring muscles. Journal of Athletic Medicine, 1(1), 45-55.