58 females with moderate neck pain of greater than 3 months duration. Exclusions were previous neck surgery or participation in a neck exercise program in the previous 12 months.
The exercise programs
Exercise programs were conducted over a six-week period. Participants received weekly supervision and instructions from an experienced physiotherapist. One regime was described as “endurance-strength training” while the other was described as “low load training of the cranio-cervical muscles”. Exercises were performed so as not to provoke neck pain.
What was measured
According to the authors, previous work had identified that patients with neck pain demonstrated a bilateral increase of sternocleidomastoid (SCM) muscle electromyography (EMG) amplitude, and a decreased ability to relax their neck muscles after the completion of a task. EMG readings were taken of the SCM muscles bilaterally. Pain and disability were also determined using a tool called the Neck Disability Index.
- Both regimes resulted in a reduction of pain.
- Neither changed or normalised the abnormal SCM activation.
What the research shows us
- Altered MAPs have been shown to cause dysfunctional movement in both the shoulder and neck.
- The treatment of MTPs was shown to normalise abnormal MAPS
- Exercise was shown to not normalise abnormal MAPs
- There was speculation that MAPs became abnormal due to pain. However, the reduction of pain failed to change the abnormal MAPs
Serious questions about exercises to remedy pain syndromes
The need for exercises as part of rehabilitation is well understood. However, lets consider at what actually happened during this trial. Subjects were shown to have an abnormal MAP. It was hypothesised that the resultant abnormal movements produced would increase adverse loading on sensitive cervical structures. Subjects in this in this dysfunctional state were instructed to do exercises, which according to the researcher’s hypothesis would place even more adverse load on the sensitive cervical structures.
After six weeks of placing extra load on those sensitive cervical structures pain had reduced but function was still abnormal. What would the consequences be of continuing to do this? Surely it would include rapid degeneration and an increased risk of injury.
Guidelines for rehabilitation
The need for exercise as part of rehabilitation is understood. However, the implications of dysfunction should be recognised. The goal should be to perform exercises using correct function. It is possible to instruct patients in “correct techniques”, but much of the function is determined at a subconscious level involving “pre-programmed” patterns, proprioception and so forth.
Put simply, it appears that MPTs and other factors that will be considered in future summaries interfere with these “pre-programmed” proprioception based patterns. Practitioners should focus on remedying these to allow the body to function normally and the body to perform rehabilitation exercises in the normal correct manner.
Don’t take all research at face value
Both exercise regimes were shown to result in a decrease in pain. Had the MAP issue not been concurrently addressed the research would have supported the use of exercises alone for neck pain sufferers, despite the fact that it doesn’t correct a key problem and would probably result in long term degeneration and an increased risk of injury.
Falla, D., Jull, G. and Hodges, P. (2008) Training the cervical muscles with prescribed motor tasks does not change muscle activation during a functional activity. Manual Therapy, 13 6: 507-512.
Samples and practitioner orders
We happily supply sample massagers to degree qualified practitioners who deal with musculoskeletal complaints, on a one per clinic basis. Please email us directly on firstname.lastname@example.org for samples or practitioner/wholesale supply.
If you found this information useful, please share:
To share this article click one of the buttons below. The Facebook button will ask to post a link to this article on your Facebook feed so your friends and colleages may see it. The twitter icon will ask to post to your Twitter account. The email icon will open your email application with a link to this article included.